Paul Einzig Primitive Money (1948) p.156
email: jonone100[at]gmail[dot]com
twitter: @jonone100
Any comments please email me or connect on Twitter.
Artwork is by James Spanfeller for Avant Garde Magazine (May 1968)
************************************************************************
Monday, January 28, 2013
Money Wisdom #70
"When an African gives coins in exchange for goods he thinks he is selling the coin against payment in grain, or cotton cloth. He does not ask the merchant how many francs (or shillings) the goods cost. He asks how much rice or calico or sugar he is prepared to give for his coin. And the price of the unit of measure remains always the same; it is the size of the measure that fluctuates."
Money Wisdom #69
[Re Slavery in Nigeria circa C19th] "Several authors blamed for the existence of slavery the absence of an easily portable currency of high value. ....The view was often expressed in those days that the introduction of coins would go a long way towards doing away with slavery. There can be no doubt that the penetration of modern money was in fact helpful in that direction."
Paul Einzig Primitive Money (1948) p.149
Money Wisdom #68
"...Money [is a] social institution which in primitive as well as modern communities provides the incentive to produce goods beyond the immediate requirements."
Paul Einzig Primitive Money (1948) p.36
Sunday, January 27, 2013
Money Wisdom #67
"Adherents of the classical economic doctrine of laisser-faire present the unspoilt savage as the true personifier of the type of Economic Man. ....Yet the study of our ethnological evidence, and even to some extent of our historical evidence, clearly indicates that this picture is entirely false.
.....Another extreme misinterpretation of the primitive character and the primitive system is represented by the theory put forward by Socialist writers, according to whom the original system of mankind was Communism... .....what is often loosely described as original Communism very often in amounted in reality to ownership by the chief of the tribe and not common ownership by members of tribe. Indeed, while in many instances the prevailing system is distinctly Communistic, in other instances private ownership is carried to extremes unknown in the most highly individualistic modern communities."
.....Another extreme misinterpretation of the primitive character and the primitive system is represented by the theory put forward by Socialist writers, according to whom the original system of mankind was Communism... .....what is often loosely described as original Communism very often in amounted in reality to ownership by the chief of the tribe and not common ownership by members of tribe. Indeed, while in many instances the prevailing system is distinctly Communistic, in other instances private ownership is carried to extremes unknown in the most highly individualistic modern communities."
Paul Einzig Primitive Money (1948) p.28 & 29
Thursday, January 24, 2013
Where does the $ sign originate?
The short answer to this question is that nobody knows. There is a good summary and links here on Roy Davies' (son of Glyn) website (scroll down to the heading "The Dollar Sign $ - Theories of its Origins").
However, one idea that Roy doesn't consider is that the origin of the dollar sign comes from the Christiann monogram which combines the three letters IHS In Hoc Signo; a Latin phrase meaning 'By this sign'. It was stamped on things like communion wafers and conveys the idea that the power of God its 'transferred' or 'accessible' through the item bearing the monogram. In other words, officially stamping IHS on something made it sacred.
This idea about the origin of the $ sign comes from Marc Shell. I've been dipping into his wonderful & beautiful Art and Money. Here are a couple of images he uses to illustrate the idea.
Firstly you can see in this carving of a chalice the letter IHS appear at the centre of the sun-like motif appearing from the cup (Shell describes it as irradiating water). Notice also the sheaves of wheat around the chalice. Desmonde makes great play of these in Magic, Myth and Money as a symbol of fertility. Shell's chapter on the Holy Grail in Money, Language and Thought tells us just how significant the idea of the grail is. It represents boundlessness. We don't know that the Grail was a chalice, but of course that's how most of us think about it. The key thing in its representation is that it's ever-giving. An infinite source for all things (which incidentally is how us Pirsigians describe Value)
However, one idea that Roy doesn't consider is that the origin of the dollar sign comes from the Christiann monogram which combines the three letters IHS In Hoc Signo; a Latin phrase meaning 'By this sign'. It was stamped on things like communion wafers and conveys the idea that the power of God its 'transferred' or 'accessible' through the item bearing the monogram. In other words, officially stamping IHS on something made it sacred.
This idea about the origin of the $ sign comes from Marc Shell. I've been dipping into his wonderful & beautiful Art and Money. Here are a couple of images he uses to illustrate the idea.
Firstly you can see in this carving of a chalice the letter IHS appear at the centre of the sun-like motif appearing from the cup (Shell describes it as irradiating water). Notice also the sheaves of wheat around the chalice. Desmonde makes great play of these in Magic, Myth and Money as a symbol of fertility. Shell's chapter on the Holy Grail in Money, Language and Thought tells us just how significant the idea of the grail is. It represents boundlessness. We don't know that the Grail was a chalice, but of course that's how most of us think about it. The key thing in its representation is that it's ever-giving. An infinite source for all things (which incidentally is how us Pirsigians describe Value)
And then this showing the three letters intertwining to form a monogram which something which looks very like a $ sign.
None of this proves anything, of course. But it does make you wonder.
And finally... I have some vague memory of this art installation being in the news. Although maybe I'm inventing it, I'm not sure. The piece was by Cildo Meireles and is called How to build Cathedrals. Up top are two thousand bones, down below are six hundred thousand coins, and connecting them is a vertical column of eight hundred Eucharist wafers (not sure if they're stamped IHS !)
This image is from Cave to Canvas where you can read more about the artwork.
I think artists are much closer to understanding money than economists.
Tuesday, January 22, 2013
Money Wisdom #66
"In particular I realized the need for laying stress on the non-commercial origin of money and on the possibility of the existence of credit before money, of money before barter and of barter before private property or division of labour in the generally accepted sense of these terms."
Paul Einzig Primitive Money (1948) introduction vi
Money Wisdom #65
"As far as possible I sought to avoid obscurities, even at the risk of failing to impress some academic economists who are inclined to regard as shallow and superficial any argument which is not obscure and over-involved."
Paul Einzig Primitive Money (1948) introduction vii
Monday, January 21, 2013
Money Wisdom #64
"If there is one conclusion that emerges forcefully from the examination of the evidence regarding the role of primitive money, it is that the true meaning of money can only be grasped if it is viewed not as a mere technical device but as a social institution of fundamental importance."
Paul Einzig Primitive Money (1948) p.456
Saturday, January 19, 2013
A Review of Magic, Myth and Money by William H Desmonde
Here's my 'sensible' review of William H Desmonde's Magic, Myth and Money. I've put it on Amazon here. If you like it please take a moment to pop over to amazon and 'like it'. Thanks.
The subtitle to William H Desmonde's 1962 Magic, Myth and Money is The Origin of Money in Religious Ritual. As such Desmonde draws on the work of German polymath Bernhard Laum who explored the idea that currency was born of religious ritual in his 1924 work Heiliges Geld (Holy Money). Desmonde's contribution is to set Laum's idea of tokens arising from the sharing of meat from ritualistic slaughter within a Freudian context. Specifically Desmonde draws on Freud's later works on society, in particular Totem and Taboo. And in doing so he offers a view on currency very much at odds with that espoused by economists. Desmonde doesn't even consider barter in his explanation for the development of currency.
The book is very readable (especially for those with a familiarity of Freud's ideas) and at 178 pages, it's a short read. I found a few reviews of the book (on JSTOR) contemporary with its publication, from various academic journals (sociological or anthropological) and all of them are generally positive (albeit with some reservations relevant to each reviewer's particular area of academic expertise). Richard F Curtis in the American Journal of Sociology (Vol. 68, No. 4 [Jan., 1963], pp. 497-498) tells us that "Desmonde performs a real service in pointing up the relevance of social science classics to one of the central moral issues of our times."
What the contemporary reviewers seem to miss about the book is its uniqueness. I've been a fan of Freud for 15 years and have had an interest in Money and the origins of currency all my life. I only came to know of the existence of Desmonde's book when I noticed it mentioned in a footnote in Marc Shell's Money, Language and Thought (p.42 n49 & n50) (a somewhat obscure book itself) which I read last year. I would take some blame myself for missing it for so long but I have made extensive inquiries about Freudian influenced views on the origin of currency and Money. Although there is some work on 'Anal' characteristics and the propensity to save, and of course some gossip about Keynes' relationship with Strachey (Freud's translator), I had not found anything that tried to meld Freud's later work with an explanation of the origin of currency. Magic, Myth and Money attempts to do this. That's why it is unique.
However, I wouldn't say that Desmonde provides a wholly convincing origin story, even for someone such as myself who is sympathetic to Freud's theories. Desmonde's book does not have sufficient rigor to support his contentions in a meaningful way. Nor does it ground itself in evidence about primitive currency to help to create solid story about currency developing from the shared meat of ritual sacrifice to coinage. A harsh charge would be to say that what Desmonde offers is merely pop-psychoanlysis beefed up with a sprinkling of aphorism. I wouldn't go that far, myself. I think it more likely that Desmonde struck a balance between academic rigor and readability. It's a balance that doesn't seem to have worked for him. The book was neither a best seller, nor held in high regard in academia.
Nevertheless this book, as it stands, still represents a unique contribution to theories about the Origin of Currency. It's an essential text for anyone interested in the history of Money. You can rest assured that you'll never have read anything like it.
The subtitle to William H Desmonde's 1962 Magic, Myth and Money is The Origin of Money in Religious Ritual. As such Desmonde draws on the work of German polymath Bernhard Laum who explored the idea that currency was born of religious ritual in his 1924 work Heiliges Geld (Holy Money). Desmonde's contribution is to set Laum's idea of tokens arising from the sharing of meat from ritualistic slaughter within a Freudian context. Specifically Desmonde draws on Freud's later works on society, in particular Totem and Taboo. And in doing so he offers a view on currency very much at odds with that espoused by economists. Desmonde doesn't even consider barter in his explanation for the development of currency.
The book is very readable (especially for those with a familiarity of Freud's ideas) and at 178 pages, it's a short read. I found a few reviews of the book (on JSTOR) contemporary with its publication, from various academic journals (sociological or anthropological) and all of them are generally positive (albeit with some reservations relevant to each reviewer's particular area of academic expertise). Richard F Curtis in the American Journal of Sociology (Vol. 68, No. 4 [Jan., 1963], pp. 497-498) tells us that "Desmonde performs a real service in pointing up the relevance of social science classics to one of the central moral issues of our times."
What the contemporary reviewers seem to miss about the book is its uniqueness. I've been a fan of Freud for 15 years and have had an interest in Money and the origins of currency all my life. I only came to know of the existence of Desmonde's book when I noticed it mentioned in a footnote in Marc Shell's Money, Language and Thought (p.42 n49 & n50) (a somewhat obscure book itself) which I read last year. I would take some blame myself for missing it for so long but I have made extensive inquiries about Freudian influenced views on the origin of currency and Money. Although there is some work on 'Anal' characteristics and the propensity to save, and of course some gossip about Keynes' relationship with Strachey (Freud's translator), I had not found anything that tried to meld Freud's later work with an explanation of the origin of currency. Magic, Myth and Money attempts to do this. That's why it is unique.
However, I wouldn't say that Desmonde provides a wholly convincing origin story, even for someone such as myself who is sympathetic to Freud's theories. Desmonde's book does not have sufficient rigor to support his contentions in a meaningful way. Nor does it ground itself in evidence about primitive currency to help to create solid story about currency developing from the shared meat of ritual sacrifice to coinage. A harsh charge would be to say that what Desmonde offers is merely pop-psychoanlysis beefed up with a sprinkling of aphorism. I wouldn't go that far, myself. I think it more likely that Desmonde struck a balance between academic rigor and readability. It's a balance that doesn't seem to have worked for him. The book was neither a best seller, nor held in high regard in academia.
Nevertheless this book, as it stands, still represents a unique contribution to theories about the Origin of Currency. It's an essential text for anyone interested in the history of Money. You can rest assured that you'll never have read anything like it.
Wednesday, January 16, 2013
Money Wisdom #63
"According to Freud's Totem and Taboo hypothesis, the animal sacrifice, from which ancient coinage arose, stemmed from a primordial Oedipus situation."
William H Desmonde Magic. Myth and Money (1962) p.162
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


